Jane Guildford Dudley: The Mystery Master Negotiator Who Saved Robert Dudley’s Neck
- Dorothea Dickerman
- 1 day ago
- 6 min read
A mother and a mistress and a friend,
A phoenix, captain and an enemy,
A guide, a goddess, and a sovereign,
A counsellor, a traitress, and a dear.
- All’s Well That Ends Well, I.i
The Dudleys – A Dynasty Almost Undone
In a previous post, 👉 The Untold Backstory of Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester: Queen Elizabeth I’s Favorite, #1 of 3, we brushed the ashes off Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester’s little-known personal tragedy – he and his brother Ambrose, the future Earl of Warwick, were the only of John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland’s eight sons to survive.
But the Dudley dynasty suffered even more devastating losses.
Of Robert’s five sisters, only Mary, who wed Henry Sidney and became the Countess of Pembroke and mother of the brilliant Mary Sidney Herbert and the dimmer Philip Sidney, and Katherine, who became Countess of Huntingdon when she married Henry Hastings, one of the last Plantagenet descendants, survived to adulthood.
Imagine growing up in a well-to-do, influential family of 13 children – then losing nine of your siblings plus your father and watching your family name squelched into the mud and your titles and possessions stripped away. That crucible forged a family survival mindset.
The four Dudley siblings became comrades-in-arms with a shared mission – to rise again from the ruins of their once-mighty family – a narrative too compelling to be left in the shadows because it reveals Robert’s character and motivations.
A future post will contain an invitation to you to attend one of Robert’s lavish entertainments for Queen Elizabeth and her court. Although you will experience feasting, hunting and elaborate spectacle, this won’t be at an ordinary Elizabethan summer house party! It’s a covert high stakes political maneuver, orchestrated by the Dudley siblings to place Robert on the throne beside Elizabeth and make their father’s dream of Dudley blood in the royal line come alive.
Spoiler Alert: It didn’t work.
Nevertheless, through every triumph and catastrophe, the Dudleys, the Sidneys, the Hastings and the Greys remained unshakably loyal to each other, even in situations where they looked enormously culpable – for good reason.
Revealing the Mastermind of the Ultimate Prison Break
All of that to come depended on the skills, connections and courage of someone working unremittingly behind the scenes. Who was the mysterious mastermind who sprung those four Dudley brothers from the Tower after they had been condemned for treason and left to rot for 15 months?
Hint #1: It was a woman.
Hint #2: She had spent time in the Tower herself on suspicion of treason.
Hint #3: She wasn’t Queen Elizabeth.
Answer: She was their mother.
Jane Guildford Dudley: A Tudor Strategist Extraordinaire
Jane Guildford Dudley was no ordinary noblewoman. She had aided her husband’s meteoric rise to power and suffered his catastrophic fall when his gambit to place Lady Jane Grey on the throne failed in 1553. You can review the details of that story here 👉 The Making of Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester: Treason, Tower, Survival, #2 of 3.
At the same time her sons and husband were imprisoned, Jane also found herself trapped in the Tower sharing tight quarters with her daughter-in-law Lady Jane Grey. Queen Mary Tudor was instructing the executioner to sharpen his ax. Rumors swirled that the Janes couldn’t stand each other, making their incarceration together particularly unbearable.
But this wasn’t Jane’s first courtly rodeo. She had ridden in Queen Jane Seymour’s funeral procession, served Queen Anne of Cleves as a lady-in-waiting, and befriended Queen Catherine Parr due to their shared evangelical beliefs. Jane was well equipped to navigate the Tudor court’s treacherous back corridors. Jane had also served Mary while she was a princess, giving her a valuable secret or two about Mary.
When the news broke of Mary’s forming an army in July of 1553, Jane’s first reaction was tears. Her second was strategy.
A Female Masterpiece: The Art of Survival
Although her husband and sons were convicted of treason, she managed to convince Mary that she personally had had no part in their plan and secured her own release. But saving her family proved a greater challenge.
Petitioning through friends failed. Mary refused to see her, preferring to focus on her impending marriage to Philip II of Spain, eleven years her junior and the most powerful man in Europe.
In August 1553, Jane’s efforts failed. Her childhood friend and husband, John Dudley, was executed on Tower Hill after publicly renouncing his Protestant faith. The entire Dudley family fell into the disgrace of attainder, stripped of titles, lands and wealth. Out of pity, Mary allowed Jane to keep her wardrobe and a few household possessions and to continue to reside in her (former) home in Chelsea, which had just become a crown property due to the attainder.
Without that grace, Jane would have been truly destitute.
Jane needed someone Mary would never refuse to plead her cause.
In February 1554, Jane’s efforts failed again: her 16-year-old son Guildford was executed on Tower Hill shortly before his wife. His godmother, Queen Mary, declined to spare him.
To save her remaining sons, Jane swallowed her Protestant pride and offered what she knew would please Mary. First, Jane asked that her sons be allowed to hear a Catholic Mass. Then, with the help of her son-in-law, Henry Sidney, Jane launched a charm offensive - courting and offering to help the Spanish nobles who were arriving in England with Philip. Strategic gift-giving of the few possessions she had left was part of her last-ditch effort.
It was a sub-rosa strategy that only a woman would devise because it was subtly aimed directly at the covert soft spot in Mary’s defensive armor: her heart. The Spanish courtiers, grateful for an insider’s assistance in navigating the English court, conveyed Jane’s pleas for mercy to Philip, Mary’s new king consort. Jane knew Mary was so besotted with her Spanish bridegroom that she would refuse him nothing.
Jane forged a very successful bond with Philip. On November 30, 1554 when a baby boy was born to Jane’s daughter Mary Sidney, his godparents were: his remarkable grandmother, Jane Guildford Dudley, and his royal majesty, King Philip II of Spain and England.
That boy’s name? Philip Sidney, of course, after his royal Spanish godfather!
Before her death in January 1555, all four of Jane’s sons had walked free of the Tower.
Conclusion: The First Woman Behind Leicester
Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester is often remembered as a political maneuverer, military commander and as Queen Elizabeth’s long-time lover. But at the most critical moment of his young life, with the Dudley dynasty teetering on extinction, his survival depended not on his own cunning, but on his mother’s clandestine efforts. Without her, the rest of my favorite Elizabethan bad boy’s story would have remained as shrouded as his grave.
Sign Up For the Party Invite! 🎉
I hope you were inspired by Jane Guildford Dudley. If you want to make sure you are on the invitation list for that glitzy summer party of Leicester’s, just click here and sign up. I will make sure you are on the guest list and send the invitation and more posts on Elizabethan Secrets straight to your inbox.
(And don’t forget to thank your own mother for everything this Mother’s Day!💐)
If you liked this post, use the buttons below to share!
