top of page

In Search of the Lost Portrait of Elizabeth Trentham, Countess of Oxford

Nov 10
9 min read

Could a 1612 will hold clues to what Edward de Vere, Earl of Oxford’s remarkable second wife looked like? 


Detail of a mysterious Elizabethan woman's portrait showing diamond buttons set in gauzy floral ornaments on black velvet, white silver brocade, strands of great pearls and the curve of her pale chin. Possibly Elizabeth Trentham, Countess of Oxford.
What can white cloth-of-silver, great pearls, and seventeen diamond buttons on a little black velvet dress tell us? Quite a bit.

After she spent a decade at Queen Elizabeth I’s court as a maid of honor, Elizabeth Trentham, Countess of Oxford (c. 1561–1612) married Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford, one of England’s highest-ranking noblemen. She helped restore order to his troubled finances and was celebrated by a court poet as a woman so striking that diamonds grew dim when she appeared.

 

She must have been gorgeous!

 

But what did she look like?

 

No portrait of Elizabeth Trentham has ever been securely identified, not even her wedding portrait. (And what Elizabethan woman would become a countess without a wedding portrait?)

 

So, if her likeness survived for more than four centuries, perhaps it is hidden under the ubiquitous label “unknown Tudor woman” or somebody else’s name. Misidentification is stock-in-trade with 400-year-old portraits.

 

Shall we go looking for her?

 

💎The First Clue Sparkles. Literally.

 

Prepare yourself. This sleuthing adventure won’t be easy. No record tells us Elizabeth’s hair color, eye color, or the shape of her nose. We have no sketch, no carved effigy. And there are hundreds of portraits of Tudor women.

 

For years, I’ve leafed through auction catalogues, comparing sitters’ ages with Elizabeth’s, and studied the size of ruffs and sleeves to roughly date paintings. I’ve haunted museums and Pinterest looking for the beautiful but modest woman whom court poets remembered for her alabaster-fair skin and unusual composure under pressure.

 

Contemporary poetry about Elizabeth offers but one semi-useful clue to her appearance.

 

“The Diamond doth lose his dainty light,

And waxeth dim, when Oxford comes in sight.”

       A Pleasant Conceit Penned in Verse, by Thomas Churchyard, 1593

 

Not a lot to go on.

 

The question is: why diamonds?

 

📜 The Next Clues Were Hiding in Plain Sight, on Paper

 

Fortunately, Elizabeth herself left us a detailed list of what was hanging in her wardrobe and tucked inside her jewelry box in 1612.

 

 In her will.

 

Reading other people’s wills is a habit of mine. Yes, it is a lawyer thing. Beneath all the legal jargon, wills are surprisingly personal documents. They tell you what people owned, certainly, but also what they valued, whom they loved and trusted, or mistrusted and conspicuously omitted, and sometimes quite a bit about their personality.

 

Elizabeth Trentham’s November 25, 1612 will is wonderfully detailed. [TNA, PROB 11/121, folios 74–75]. She left her most valuable possessions, including thirteen diamond buttons, to her surviving child, Henry de Vere, 18th Earl of Oxford, graced with words of motherly wit and humor. She gave items of her everyday clothing to her serving women and very expensive court attire to close Trentham and de Vere family relatives. Tudor clothing, especially when made of costly fabrics like silk and velvet like Elizabeth’s, was highly prized. She gave cash to servants and generously remembered the poor of Castle Hedingham and Hackney. She even remembered “my dumb man”, whoever he may have been.

 

Now that we have another connection between Elizabeth Trentham and diamonds, and a shopping list, let’s go portrait shopping!


Enjoying this historical detective story?


I spend my time tracking Elizabethans through wills, letters, portraits, houses, court records, and occasionally sheep fields and Italian piazzas, to find the stories they left behind that don’t make the history books. 

 

 Join my readers and I'll send a box of exclusive secrets 🎁 and the next mystery 🔎 straight to your inbox.  


“It just gets better and better. Thank you!”  - A YouTube commenter


 

                                   

👗 Can We Make a Match?

 

Can we match any of the clothing and jewels that Elizabeth listed in her will to any portraits of Tudor women? 

 

This investigation will take some time. Make that, a lot of time. Patience.

 

But here’s one.


Full-length Elizabethan portrait of a pale-skinned woman wearing a black velvet gown over a white cloth-of-silver kirtle, adorned with pearls and diamond buttons. She holds a feather fan before red drapery. Traditionally identified as Elizabeth Southwell; possibly Elizabeth Trentham, Countess of Oxford.
This luminous Tudor lady dressed to impress in a wardrobe that bears a resemblance to the one Elizabeth Trentham left behind.

An international auction house sold a portrait in 2011, artist unnamed, of a fair-skinned woman described initially as “unnamed woman” (of course), then possibly “Elizabeth Howard”. Then, rather cautiously: “Portrait of a Lady, probably Elizabeth Southwell, nee Howard, eldest daughter of Charles Howard, 1st Earl Nottingham.” 

 

See what I mean about shifting identifications on Tudor portraits? Nevertheless, let’s compare what she is wearing to what Elizabeth left in her will.

 

Among the items Elizabeth bequeathed in her will: 

 

Thirteen diamond buttons to her son Henry.


 A rope of great pearls to her son Henry.


A black velvet gown to her sister Catherine.


A white cloth-of-silver kirtle to her sister Catherine.

 

Portrait:


           The luminous lady in the portrait is attired in an expensive black velvet court dress.  ✅

 

   Beneath it, she wears a white cloth-of-silver kirtle. ✅

 

   Around her neck hang long ropes of “great” pearls. ✅

 

Now count the gauzy flowers pinned to her sleeves and the front of her gown.

 

Six on one shoulder. Four on the other. And six down the front of her skirt.

 

Each of those flowers is pinned at its center by a diamond button, confirmed by the gallery that most recently sold the painting. Our mystery lady is wearing sixteen diamond buttons. 

 

But wait! Look at the top of her white cloth-of-silver kirtle. She wears a seventeenth diamond button.

 

Seventeen diamond buttons.

 

Edward de Vere was the seventeenth Earl of Oxford.

 

Well now.

 

Happenstance? Or was the lady wearing seventeen diamond clues to button up her identity?

 

Diamond buttons can be lost, stolen or sold. They can be fashioned into other jewelry like her diamonds hairpins or those strung on her girdle amid the pearls.

 

The lady wears seventeen diamond buttons and Elizabeth bequeathed thirteen diamond buttons to her son. Nothing inconsistent there. ✅

 

But that‘s not enough to identify her.

 

👩🏻‍🦰 Only One Problem: The Lady in the Portrait Already Had a Name.

 

The gallery that bought the portrait sold it the next year as one of three “Howard Lady Portraits”, identified as Catherine Carey, Countess of Nottingham and two of her daughters, this portrait as (no longer “more probably”) Elizabeth Howard Southwell.

 

With unmarked portraits this old, provenance can greatly influence guesses at the sitter’s identity.  The provenance that came with the portrait credited Elizabeth Southwell’s daughter Catherine’s 1618 marriage to Sir Greville Verney, de jure Seventh Baron Willoughby de Broke (1586-1624), as the means by which the portrait entered the collection of and then descended through the  Willoughby de Broke barony until its 1912 Sotheby’s London sale.  

 

I inquired of the gallery and the auction house about documentation supporting the provenance, and looked independently myself, but no evidence surfaced proving that this portrait came into the Willoughby de Broke barony’s collection through the Seventh Baron’s marriage in 1618. 

 

If the sitter were Elizabeth Southwell, the portrait could have entered the family through her daughter’s 1618 marriage.

 

But there was no proof, not even a whiff.

 

What’s really interesting is that if the sitter were Elizabeth Trentham, there was another way the portrait could have come into the same family’s collection – nine years earlier.

 

Let’s follow that lead and see where it goes.

 

🏰 Elizabeth Trentham, King’s Place and Fulke Greville, de jure Fifth Baron Willoughby de Broke

 

The Ashbourne Portrait, a painting of a bearded Elizabethan gentleman in black clothing with a white ruff, holding a book beside a table with a skull. A dark background contains a coat of arms and inscription, with red areas visible near the table. The sitter has been identified variously as Shakespeare, Hugh Hamersley and Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford.
The Ashbourne portrait. He has been called “Shakespeare”, “unknown”, “Hugh Hamersley” and “Edward de Vere”. Perhaps his wife could help settle the argument.

On April 1, 1609, nine years before Catherine Southwell married the Seventh Baron, Elizabeth Trentham received parliamentary permission to sell Kings Place (thereafter called “Brooke House”), the enormous estate and house in which she lived with Oxford, to Sir Fulke Greville, de jure Fifth Baron Willoughby de Broke (1554-1628) [TNA C 66/1819, m.36]. Kings Place boasted a very fine long gallery, typically used in Tudor houses for displaying family portraits.

 

Fulke Greville was an old friend of Oxford’s. As young men, they had together staged a mock battle for the court’s entertainment during the summer progress at Warwick Castle.  You can join in the fun of that escapade gone amiss, due to a fire-breathing dragon here:  Let's Party Like It's 1572: Elizabeth I's Summer Progress and the Fireworks That Set Off the Dudley vs. De Vere Rivalry.

 

So Fulke’s purchase of Kings Place raises the possibility that this portrait entered the same Willoughby de Broke family collection nine years earlier.

 

🫶 Just for Fun: The Ashbourne Portrait and Elizabeth Trentham’s Portraits Side by Side

 

What happens if we place the portrait that may be Elizabeth Trentham beside another mystery portrait, a famous one, the Ashbourne owned by The Folger Shakespeare Library?

 

The Ashbourne’s sitter has had at least as many identities as our mysterious lady:  William Shakespeare, a 1627 Lord Mayor of London named Hugh Hamersley, an “unknown nobleman”, and Elizabeth Trentham’s husband, Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford. Portions of the portrait, including the sitter’s hairline, his signet ring, his ruff, the year, and the family crest, have so obviously been altered, obscured, or painted over, that even the Folger's former director acknowledged it as we stood side by side admiring the painting.

 

Which raises the obvious question: why? Who would go to such trouble for Hammersley, a Mayor of London for one year? And surely, anyone hoping this was an elusive portrait of Shakespeare would want the identifying evidence revealed, not concealed.

 

Curiously, the Folger hung the mystery man for years in a sitting room, directly across from the only other portrait in the room, its famous “Sieve” portrait of Queen Elizabeth, as if the two were old friends with a lot to talk about. Whoever the Folger thought he was, they gave him royal company.

 

Now, let’s set the Ashbourne face to face with the luminous lady’s portrait.

 

They mirror each other. She holds a jeweled ostrich feather fan, and he, a book. Their fingers almost reach through the frames to caress. Both wear costly, saturated black velvet that required repeated and skilled dyeing. Whoever they are, this couple is wearing very expensive clothing for a formal occasion, not necessarily for mourning.

 

But look behind them.


The Ashbourne Portrait alongside full-length Elizabethan portrait of a pale-skinned woman wearing a black velvet gown over a white cloth-of-silver kirtle, adorned with pearls and diamond buttons, traditionally identified as Elizabeth Southwell; possibly Elizabeth Trentham, Countess of Oxford. The Ashbourne Portrait sitter has been identified variously as Shakespeare, Hugh Hamersley and Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford.

 

The Ashbourne’s background is almost completely black, a very odd choice when the sitter is also dressed completely in black.  And see those two curious large patches of bright red? One, the irregular dark-red rectangles on the forward side of the table, are remarkably similar to the irregular dark-red rectangles in the background of the lady’s portrait. 

 

Could it be that these two much-debated portraits were a pair, commissioned to celebrate the 1591 wedding of Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford and Elizabeth Trentham, and meant to hang in the King’s Place long gallery?

 

I don’t know. But if they are not, there is a pile of coincidences to be explained.

 

Find out more about Elizabeth’s and Oxford’s romance set against some riotously fun Elizabethan court scandal here:

 

 

🧐 Is the Painting Identified as Elizabeth Southwell Really Elizabeth Trentham?

 

 Here again are the clues to the identity of the luminous and mysterious woman in the portrait:

 

1.     After trying on “unidentified woman” and Elizabeth Howard, a major international auction house hedged its bets big time that she was “more probably”, but not definitively, Elizabeth Southwell.


2.      The portrait may have come to the Willoughby de Broke family either through:

(a)    the de jure Seventh Baron in 1618 based on the assumption that Elizabeth Southwell was the sitter; or

(b)   earlier through Fulke Greville, de jure Fifth Baron, the 1609 documented purchaser from Elizabeth Trentham of Brooke House, her home with Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford, based on the assumption that Elizabeth Trentham was the sitter.


3.     Several items of apparel and jewelry (including seventeen diamond buttons) in the portrait match items bequeathed by Elizabeth Trentham to close family members in her 1612 will.


4.     The unusual red-rectangles in the background of the portrait match a portion of the background in the Ashbourne portrait whose sitter also has had many possible identities, including Elizabeth Trentham’s husband, Edward de Vere.


5.      The portraits are of similar size, attitude, attire and style, suggesting that the two portraits are possibly a matching pair of marriage portraits.

 

So, now you have done the detective work. What do you think the truth is underpinning this Elizabethan secret? Is it more likely than not that the portrait identified as “probably” Elizabeth Southwell actually depicts Elizabeth Trentham de Vere, Countess of Oxford?

 

One thing is certain: whoever the mysterious lady in the portrait really is, she definitely outshines her diamonds!

 


🦢More About Elizabeth Trentham

 

Want to keep following Elizabeth Trentham and uncover other Elizabethan Secrets with me?

 

Subscribe to The Secret Lives of Elizabethans and I'll let you know when I uncover something new and send you a thank you box of exclusive secrets.

 

You can follow me to Elizabeth’s hometown of Rocester, Staffordshire, and find out why I was out standing in a sheep field to learn more about her:

 

 

 You can explore Elizabeth’s role in setting right the finances of Oxford’s earldom:

 

 

🎥 And you can watch this illustrated lecture on YouTube about Elizabeth’s life:

 

 

Subscribe-post
Hilliard-Man-760.png

Don’t miss a single scandal!

Hop in the time machine to get the latest news from 400 years ago and receive a FREE ebook, "8 Elizabethan Facts You May Think are Historical Fiction... But You Would be Mistaken"!

bottom of page